You are currently not signed in.

Please sign in or register.

The performance % gain stat

页数: 1
May 24, 2012 11:18 am
#1
CFXsignals User

帖子: 359
入会日期: 21/05/2012

Does anyone know how the % gain is calculated on the performance stats - at the moment, the headline % gain seems unrelated to the actual % gain per month.  Is it just based on the increase in account size from the initial deposit?  In that case couldn't someone just deposit $1 in their account, and periodically deposit $1 a month, making 100% gain in a month?  The profit % needs to be calculated surely as absolute profit - the % of gain from trading divided by (total amount of money deposited - amount withdrawn) otherwise the stat is worthless, and makes navigating the performance forum difficult.

May 24, 2012 05:31 pm
Bee User

帖子: 29
入会日期: 09/05/2011

The percentage gain on top of statement is actually time-weighted return. It is also known as geometric mean return. 

Bee There is no term like "sufficient money". So aim for a satisfied life.

May 24, 2012 06:37 pm
CFXsignals User

帖子: 359
入会日期: 21/05/2012

But I have seen several accounts with 1000s of % that don't add up if you look at the monthly gains - hence it must include other factors other than trading gains

May 25, 2012 03:10 am
Bee User

帖子: 29
入会日期: 09/05/2011

Originally posted by CFXsignals
But I have seen several accounts with 1000s of % that don't add up if you look at the monthly gains - hence it must include other factors other than trading gains


Yes, some traders do have percentage gain that is not true. It is because their trading data doesnt show full statement. They have not selected all trading history from their metatrader platform. That is why we see insanely high profit percentage.  

Bee There is no term like "sufficient money". So aim for a satisfied life.

May 25, 2012 07:41 am
CFXsignals User

帖子: 359
入会日期: 21/05/2012

Can you choose the time period to include all of metatrader in that case as a viewer, or is that strictly controlled by the signal provider?

May 26, 2012 11:24 am
Champ User

帖子: 711
入会日期: 17/05/2011

Trader cannot choose selective time period. But if he do not choose all timeframe from metatrader platform then it will not show full trading history. but only of last 3 months or maybe 1 month. It depends on what is selected.

http://www.fxstat.com/widget/link?t=tiny&c=1&s=24959&o1=growth&o2=drawdown&o3=profitfactor

May 26, 2012 01:08 pm
CFXsignals User

帖子: 359
入会日期: 21/05/2012

So basically the trader is able to hide their trading history from people, but not selectively.  Then only signal services with a 6 month time period would be worth looking at in that case.

Jun 14, 2012 12:17 pm

帖子: 66
入会日期: 08/06/2012

Originally posted by CFXsignals

But I have seen several accounts with 1000s of % that don't add up if you look at the monthly gains - hence it must include other factors other than trading gains

 



 

What other factor can be that must be trading gain that a trader get after trading. If ther is any doubt than we can clear that with while checking the statement which shoes the transections. But when we talk about the gain taht's purly the profit that a trader earn.

Game is not over Till it's Over

Jun 14, 2012 01:42 pm
CFXsignals User

帖子: 359
入会日期: 21/05/2012

Thats what should be reflected in the headline stat - profit over the deposit.

Jul 06, 2012 03:20 pm

帖子: 194
入会日期: 26/04/2012

Yeah you can make 100% profit with forex trading but remember do not re-invest your funds again and again and never became greedy and just trade with some concentration and emotions like patients.

页数: 1