We dont need to depend on others because we are the one whos making experience and decision  for our own good,and we are the one whos controlling to manage how our trading will be successful.

For counter arguement sake im going to take up the enemy camp position and say rookies who know little about trading are likely to wuit after they lose their initial deposit, in this sense relying on Copy-trading is not necessarily a bad thing to depend on while they learn.

Now as a reminder i do agree with your points, but to balance the argument i see copy-trading as the trainning wheels of a bicycle. Its also good to have 1 or 2 signal providers in your portfolio in case you are ever in a slump.

 

I agree that we should not be dependent on other traders to learn forex trading because you can't expect successful traders to share their hard-earned working strategy,not even for money you can lure them to share those.

independent learning,depending on your skills and using manual trading will boost your skills and abilities to come up with a good strategy for your own.

Originally posted by rrayne20009

I agree that we should not be dependent on other traders to learn forex trading because you can't expect successful traders to share their hard-earned working strategy,not even for money you can lure them to share those.

independent learning,depending on your skills and using manual trading will boost your skills and abilities to come up with a good strategy for your own.

 

I'm going to join the counter argument camp and say but some brokers offer a service where a signal provider will only get paid his comission only if he has earned money for the follower (i think this is called high water mark), in this case he would WANT to share the profits of his strategy because he would earn additiaonl profit. 

in this sense while the profits would not reflect your individual skills this would be profitable for you regardless.
 

Of course, you can only depend on yourself with regards to Forex trading. Your trading success would only rely on your own trading skills and experience. But you can use others as your guide, their own experiences and knowledge, guide to your trading needs so you won't commit the mistakes that they did in trading.

Originally posted by leebelisar

Of course, you can only depend on yourself with regards to Forex trading. Your trading success would only rely on your own trading skills and experience. But you can use others as your guide, their own experiences and knowledge, guide to your trading needs so you won't commit the mistakes that they did in trading.

if we want to be a good forex trader then we should trade in forex market by learning and if we are skillful to trade there we will make money from the internet easily forex market profit making is depends on the traders skill where they trade and what they trade and how they trade 

Originally posted by zahidbd9

if we want to be a good forex trader then we should trade in forex market by learning and if we are skillful to trade there we will make money from the internet easily forex market profit making is depends on the traders skill where they trade and what they trade and how they trade 

I agree with this, I found a good way to learn is to employ a money manager, but while you're using their service reach an agreement they should also teach you about how they trade on the way. 

(My most recent trades are a good indication of how succesful this can be)